Free PDF Through a Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March to Quebec, 1775, by Thomas A. Desjardin
Some people might be giggling when taking a look at you checking out Through A Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March To Quebec, 1775, By Thomas A. Desjardin in your leisure. Some could be appreciated of you. And some could want resemble you who have reading leisure activity. Just what concerning your very own feel? Have you really felt right? Reviewing Through A Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March To Quebec, 1775, By Thomas A. Desjardin is a demand and a hobby at the same time. This problem is the on that particular will make you feel that you must review. If you know are trying to find the book entitled Through A Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March To Quebec, 1775, By Thomas A. Desjardin as the choice of reading, you can discover here.
Through a Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March to Quebec, 1775, by Thomas A. Desjardin
Free PDF Through a Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March to Quebec, 1775, by Thomas A. Desjardin
Through A Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March To Quebec, 1775, By Thomas A. Desjardin. Thanks for visiting the most effective website that supply hundreds kinds of book collections. Here, we will provide all books Through A Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March To Quebec, 1775, By Thomas A. Desjardin that you require. Guides from well-known authors and authors are given. So, you could take pleasure in currently to get one by one type of publication Through A Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March To Quebec, 1775, By Thomas A. Desjardin that you will browse. Well, related to the book that you want, is this Through A Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March To Quebec, 1775, By Thomas A. Desjardin your choice?
This letter may not affect you to be smarter, but guide Through A Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March To Quebec, 1775, By Thomas A. Desjardin that our company offer will certainly stimulate you to be smarter. Yeah, at the very least you'll recognize greater than others that don't. This is just what called as the quality life improvisation. Why ought to this Through A Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March To Quebec, 1775, By Thomas A. Desjardin It's considering that this is your preferred theme to read. If you like this Through A Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March To Quebec, 1775, By Thomas A. Desjardin motif about, why do not you read guide Through A Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March To Quebec, 1775, By Thomas A. Desjardin to improve your conversation?
The presented book Through A Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March To Quebec, 1775, By Thomas A. Desjardin we offer here is not kind of usual book. You know, reviewing currently doesn't suggest to deal with the published book Through A Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March To Quebec, 1775, By Thomas A. Desjardin in your hand. You could get the soft data of Through A Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March To Quebec, 1775, By Thomas A. Desjardin in your gadget. Well, we indicate that guide that we extend is the soft documents of the book Through A Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March To Quebec, 1775, By Thomas A. Desjardin The content and all points are exact same. The difference is just the types of guide Through A Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March To Quebec, 1775, By Thomas A. Desjardin, whereas, this condition will precisely pay.
We share you likewise the way to get this book Through A Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March To Quebec, 1775, By Thomas A. Desjardin without going to guide shop. You could continue to go to the link that we provide and also all set to download and install Through A Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March To Quebec, 1775, By Thomas A. Desjardin When many individuals are busy to seek fro in the book store, you are extremely simple to download the Through A Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March To Quebec, 1775, By Thomas A. Desjardin right here. So, exactly what else you will choose? Take the inspiration here! It is not only offering the appropriate book Through A Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March To Quebec, 1775, By Thomas A. Desjardin however also the best book collections. Right here we always offer you the best and also easiest way.
In September 1775, eleven hundred soldiers boarded ships in Newburyport, bound for the Maine wilderness. They were American colonists who had volunteered for a secret mission to paddle and march nearly two hundred miles through some of the wildest country in the colonies and seize the fortress city of Quebec, the last British stronghold in Canada.
The march, under the command of Colonel Benedict Arnold, proved to be a tragic journey. Before they reached the outskirts of Quebec, hundreds died from hypothermia, drowning, small pox, lightning strikes, exposure, and starvation. The survivors ate dogs, shoes, clothing, leather, cartridge boxes, shaving soap, and lip salve. Their trek toward Quebec was nearly twice the length shown on their maps. In the midst of the journey, the most unlikely of events befell them: a hurricane. The rains fell in such torrents that their boats floated off or sunk, taking their meager provisions along, and then it began to snow. The men woke up frozen in their tattered clothing. One third of the force deserted, returning to Massachusetts. Of those remaining, more than four hundred were killed, wounded, or taken prisoner.
Finally, in the midst of a raging blizzard, those remaining attacked Quebec. In the assault, their wet muskets failed to fire. Undaunted, they overtook the first of two barricades and pressed on toward the other, nearly taking Canada from the British. Demonstrating Benedict Arnold's prowess as a military strategist, the attack on Quebec accomplished another goal for the colonial army: It forced the British to commit thousands of troops to Canada, subsequently weakening the British hand against George Washington.
A great military history about the early days of the American Revolution, Through a Howling Wilderness is also a timeless adventure narrative that tells of heroic acts, men pitted against nature's fury, and a fledgling nation's fight against a tyrannical oppressor.
- Sales Rank: #1639723 in Books
- Published on: 2006-01
- Released on: 2005-12-27
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 8.44" h x 1.04" w x 5.76" l,
- Binding: Hardcover
- 256 pages
From Publishers Weekly
In June 1775, Benedict Arnold—having not yet turned traitor, and, indeed, lionized as one of the 13 colonies' great military hopes—proposed an invasion of Quebec. He thought a successful attack might dispose King George to redress the colonists' grievances. With General Washington's approval, Arnold gathered together a group of soldiers and headed north. Desjardin (These Honored Dead: How the Story of Gettysburg Shaped American Memory) describes the grueling expedition. The soldiers quickly ran low on food, and, among other disasters, a canoe was ripped apart by a tree branch, almost costing half the men their lives. Eventually, some of the troops made it to Canada, and after backup arrived, they attacked Quebec Though the attempt was unsuccessful and Arnold was wounded, he was praised for simply having made it from Maine to Canada. Desjardin's account is able, though at times melodramatic ("Thousands of issues must have weighed heavily upon Arnold's mind") and cute (two centuries before Dr. Atkins, Arnold's men "discovered the weight-loss capacities" of low-carb eating). Perhaps the most important section is the epilogue, in which Desjardin suggests that a successful attack on Quebec might actually have hampered the fight for American independence. (Jan. 8)
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
From Booklist
Rather too late in 1775, American generals Benedict Arnold and Richard Montgomery set off to assault Quebec, the main fortress of British Canada, at the head of an exceedingly modest force of Continental soldiers. They faced grueling portages, swamps, insects, trackless forests, hostile Indians, Quebecois not eager to be liberated by the staunchly Protestant New Englanders, and supply shortages of every conceivable kind. They finally reached Quebec in the dead of winter, to find it desperately defended by the British. After attempting a siege, they assaulted the walled city. The assault failed, with Montgomery killed and Arnold wounded, which Desjardin, state historian of Maine, suggests may have been a fatal blow to the campaign. The survivors retreated even more precariously than they had advanced. Thoroughly researched and well written, this is likely to be the standard history of the campaign for some time to come. Roland Green
Copyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved
Review
"Desjardin is able to portray fascinating, vivid characters, more human and more credible than the leaders who organized the expedition."--Associated Press "[A] stirring account...Desjardin has salted his account with great bits of regional history."--The Boston Globe "In an age of bloated, overstuffed history books...Desjardin has pulled off this feat in just 240 pages of terse, well-hewn prose."--The Bangor Daily News "Thoroughly researched and well written, this is likely to be the standard history of the campaign for some time to come."—Booklist "Desjardin recounts the march in descriptive, detailed prose studded with visceral imagery . . . A vivid narrative of a vital American event.'"—Kirkus Reviews "[A] highly readable book."--The Journal Star "One of the great adventure sagas in American history . . . This is a story that helped shape the American Revolution, dramatically told in this highly readable new book."—James Kirby Martin, author of the award-winning Benedict Arnold, Revolutionary Hero: An American Warrior Reconsidered "A model of accessible, vigorous narrative history, Through a Howling Wilderness re-creates an important but largely forgotten episode in early American history and tells a fascinating story in the bargain."—Jackson Lears, Board of Governors Professor of History, Rutgers University
Most helpful customer reviews
20 of 21 people found the following review helpful.
Composite Tale From Sometimes Questionable Sources
By David M. Dougherty
Arnold's march to Quebec is a subject that an historian can research almost completely with little effort. Kenneth Roberts did us all a favor with his 1938 "March To Quebec" while writing Arundel, a fictional account of the campaign, which included almost all of the known and important journals by members of Arnold's expedition. Desjardin could almost have written his book from this single source, and in fact his end notes reference Roberts extensively. The journals contained in Roberts and an additional two dozen references cover 99+ percent of the known information concerning the march and the battle for Quebec with Roberts accounting for probably 80%.
In short, this book is a weaving of those journals into a narrative, complete with the inaccuracies and exaggerations in those journals. Most of the references listed are peripheral to the journals, even the primary sources, and the chapter on "America'a Hannibal" is superfluous in that it deals with Arnold in other campaigns. The reader is cautioned that this light read lacks the depth of analysis and discussion normally expected in a historical work. One could read the journals contained in Roberts's book and perhaps come away with a better appreciation of the travails and experiences of this campaign.
The march itself was probably best handled in an unreferenced work of 1903 by Justin Smith, "Arnold's March From Cambridge To Quebec." John Codman's 1901 work, "Arnold's Expedition to Quebec" also covers the ground well, although it contains information that has been impossible to verify from other sources or critical analysis. The battle is covered relatively poorly in primary sources, with the usual contradictory accounts, especially with respect to Arnold's attack on the lower town. Morgan's actions at the barricades fall more properly into the realm of myth-making, although clearly the riflemen fought as well as they could. The saga of the captured Americans, (of which my Great-great-great-grandfather James Dougherty of Smith's Lancaster Riflemen and who then violated his parole and fought in Washington's army until 1783 was one), is covered at any length only in Henry's journal, a page of two in others including several British sources, and a few letters and other documents such as those by James Dougherty. That Quebec would never have become the 14th colony to rebel and the capture of Quebec would have cost the patriots more than they would gain is also a fairly common opinion among historians.
In short, I recommend other works concerning Arnold's expedition for the casual historian of the Revolutionary period such as Roberts for the journals, Smith for a critical analysis of the march, and Arthur Lefkowitz's "Benedict Arnold's Army" for the overall invasion. But Desjardin's book is what it is, a composite of the stories as recorded by the participants.
0 of 0 people found the following review helpful.
As a Mainer who grew up on the shores of ...
By G. Rudmin
As a Mainer who grew up on the shores of Lake Champlain in northern NY, I found the book totally fascinating.
5 of 15 people found the following review helpful.
Reuben Colburn's Dilemma
By Mark A. York
Desjardin writes a familiar overview narrative of the March to Quebec, my Colburn family story, with little analysis until the speculative epilogue concerning what would have happened if they had succeeded in capturing Quebec City. En route folks are left out if their name is Colburn. After Skowhegan and Norridgewock Colburn's Company simply disappears when evidence says they were still marching and involved all the way to the Canadian border, their scouts beyond that. The Getchells fare much better getting a whole chapter based on their family history and myths including a fascinating buried treasure tale. None of the journals mention seeing, let alone carrying and lamenting its loss, a barrel of coins all the way to the upper Dead River, as depicted here.
It is widely known that the journal of John Joseph Henry, later a judge written with his daughter on his deathbed, was wildly inaccurate and the worst of all the journals according to Kenneth Roberts. Roberts skewered both Colburn and scout Dennis Getchell in Arundel but to his credit Desjardin corrects most of that. Colburn is defended early on for his bateaux and the lack of dried lumber, shortness of time, and even more importantly, he adds the lack of forged nails to the defense and should be applauded for that new addition. The story skims past Colburn's shipyard and home, and doesn't mention the three days Arnold spent as guests of Reuben and Elizabeth, not to mention the army encamped in the yard. Moreover, he doesn't include any Colburn family history as a pertinent backstory at all. How strange for the Historic Site Specialist for the Colburn House State Historic Site. Too close to home?
Colburn gathered the tribes of the St. Francis and took them to Cambridge not the other way around as portrayed here. That was how "he just happened to be in Cambridge in Aug. 14, 1775." There are other misfires like Mathias Ogden, the cousin of Aaron Burr portrayed as a "friend" and "chum"; the overuse of "Natives" and "Native Americans" instead of what they were: Abenakis. This may be credited to editors? The botching of the Natanis narrative is troubling as a scholar on this particular subject. It's a twisted tale for sure and I can't reveal the evidence I have except that I have it from primary sources, but it's common knowledge from the journals that Natanis rescued the lost companies in the Spider lake swamp. Desjardin's constant infusing of what Arnold "must have felt" are intrusive in my view, and smack of "tell-don't-show, instead of the other way around.
At any rate, it's an extensively researched, albeit short work, and I recommend it even if it is the one that preempted my own, Patriot on the Kennebec, from publication, possibly forever. Any publicity is better than none. And as with the haggard soldiers of Arnold's army, the future is unknowable from where we sit.
Through a Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March to Quebec, 1775, by Thomas A. Desjardin PDF
Through a Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March to Quebec, 1775, by Thomas A. Desjardin EPub
Through a Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March to Quebec, 1775, by Thomas A. Desjardin Doc
Through a Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March to Quebec, 1775, by Thomas A. Desjardin iBooks
Through a Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March to Quebec, 1775, by Thomas A. Desjardin rtf
Through a Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March to Quebec, 1775, by Thomas A. Desjardin Mobipocket
Through a Howling Wilderness: Benedict Arnold's March to Quebec, 1775, by Thomas A. Desjardin Kindle
No comments:
Post a Comment